Skip to main content
The Old '76 House logo top - HomepageThe Old '76 House logo scroll - Homepage
  • Facebook page
  • Instagram page
  • Google page
  • Menu
  • Drinks
  • *
  • music calendar
  • History
  • cards/Merch
  • Happenings
  • Private Events
  • Facebook page
  • Instagram page
  • Google page

Our Menu

  • Lunch Menu
  • Dinner Menu
  • After Dinner Delights
  • Kids Menu
  • Buffet Banquet Menu
  • Banquet Lunch Menu
  • Banquet Dinner Menu

Price reflects a credit card processing fee which is not collected or received by the tavern. We offer a 3.9% discount for guests paying with cash.

An American Lunch

Tavern Fish and Chips
$19.00

76 House Tavernkeeper beer battered Alaskan Cod, served with house fries, tartar sauce and malt vinegar.

Chicken Pot Pie
$22.00

Our roasted Amish chicken and garden vegetables within a creamy velouté, served in a tender puff pastry shell.

Shepherd’s Pie
$19.00

Cast iron seared ground Angus beef and garden vegetables simmered in a rich Bordelaise, topped with mashed potato.

Traditional American Meatloaf
$18.00

Blended chop meat with caramelized onion and Asiago cheese, over mashed potato with a rich brown gravy.

Shrimp Scampi
$22.00

Sauteed Gulf shrimp, pesto, sundried tomatoes & scallions over linguini

'76 Classic Tableside Caesar Salad
$22.00

Romaine, garlic croutons and the classic dressing prepared at your table
Grilled Chicken $10.00 | Shrimp $12.00 | Salmon $12.00

Chinois Salad
$17.00

Shaved Napa cabbage, romaine, candied cashews, carrots, bell peppers, wontons, with ginger-soy dressing
Grilled Chicken $10.00 | Shrimp $12.00 | Salmon $12.00

Arugula Salad
$17.00

Baby arugula, crumbled goat cheese, cranberries, toasted pecans and a white balsamic vinaigrette
Grilled Chicken $10.00 | Shrimp $12.00 | Salmon $12.00

The Seafarer Sandwich
$19.00

Atlantic Cod, porter ale golden fried, tartar sauce, brioche roll

'The 76 Best' Tavern Burger
$25.00

A composed burger of our blend of short rib brisket & NY sirloin, NY sirloin, with caramelized onion, bacon, gruyere, Bordelaise

The Octoberfest
$18.00

Bavarian Bratwurst, sauerkraut, toasted hoggie roll & whole grain-dijon mustard

Grilled Chicken Caprese Sandwich
$19.00

Lightly breaded chicken cutlet on brioche bun, pesto, mayo, arugula, fresh mozzarella

Reuben Sandwich on Rye
$19.00

Thinly sliced corn beef, Swiss, Kraut, & thousand island dressing

The Thanksgiving Sandwich
$19.00

Home roasted turkey breast, American stuffing, cranberry aioli

Crab Cake Burger
$22.00

Maryland lump crab, celery, onion, house seasoning, panko & cilantro lime aioli on brioche bun

Price reflects a credit card processing fee which is not collected or received by the tavern. We offer a 3.9% discount for guests paying with cash.

Appetizers

Famous Onion Soup Lafayette
$12.00

En crock, au gratin. For in restaurant dining only.

Thanksgiving Spring Roll
$18.00

Roasted turkey, cornbread stuffing, cranberry aioli.

Maine Mussels Meuniere
$19.00

Gluten free | Chardonnay, garlic, thyme, tomato, grilled garlic crostini.

Top Neck Baked-Stuffed Clams
$18.00

Fresh shucked, parmesan oreganata.

Classic Shrimp Cocktail
$18.00

Gluten free | Gulf shrimp, ’76 cocktail sauce.

Grilled Flatbread
$17.00

Roasted butternut squash and garlic purée, caramelized onions, shaved Brussels sprouts, gruyere, chili-bacon jam.

The Crab Cake
$19.00

Maryland blue claw lump crabmeat, simple, lightly breaded, delicious, sauce beurre blanc.

Alligator Empanadas
$18.00

Sour cream & plum tomato concasse.

Entrees

The ‘76 Famous Pork Chop
$38.00

Grilled double-cut Berkshire pork chop, Hudson Valley apple-brandy glaze, sweet mashed potato.

Vegan Moussaka
$29.00

Gluten free, Vegan | The classic casserole made entirely with plant based ingredients, a new favorite!

Venison Medallions
$40.00

Gluten free | Wild American axis red deer, puree of sweet potato, lingonberry-madeira compote.

Duckling Hamilton
$40.00

Gluten free | Oranges, gran marnier glaze, sweet potato.

Jumbo Diver Scallops ‘76
$38.00

Gluten free | Jumbo sea scallops, seared red onion, house risotto, deglazed with port wine.

'76 House Yankee Pot Roast
$36.00

Sweet cabbage, mashed potato, popover.

Local Trout Trieste
$33.00

Gluten free | Sullivan County brook trout, boned and pan-seared, fresh crisped herb sauce, served with house risotto.

Jägerschnitzel
$36.00

Escalope of pork, Austrian Spätzle, red cabbage, mushroom cognac demi-glaze.

The ‘76 Tavern Burger
$25.00

A composed burger of our blend of short rib & NY sirloin, topped with onion, bacon, gruyere, Bordelaise and served with french fries.

Black Angus New York Sirloin
$48.00

Finest Black Angus 14 oz NY Sirloin steak, flame grilled, served with roasted garlic mashed potato and beer battered onion rings.

Amish Chicken
$32.00

1/2 Lancaster roast chicken, Thanksgiving stuffing, and American pan gravy served with mashed potatoes.

Salmon Terrine
$35.00

Baked Faroe Island Salmon wrapped around a shrimp & scallop stuffing finished with a lobster chive vin blanc.

Classic Chicken Cordon Bleu
$32.00

Virginia ham, gruyere, golden crust, cognac creme.

Broccoli Rabe & Sausage Rigatoni
$36.00

Broccoli rabe, sweet & hot Italian sausage, garlic aioli, & fresh mozzarella

Salads

additional: Chicken $10, Shrimp $12, Salmon $12,

‘76 Classic Tableside Caesar Romaine
$22.00

Romaine, garlic crouton and the classic dressing prepared at your table. For in restaurant dining only.

Chinois Salad
$17.00

Shaved Napa cabbage, romaine, candied cashews, carrots, bell peppers, wontons, ginger-soy dressing.

Baby Arugula Salad
$17.00

Baby arugula, crumbled goat cheese, cranberries, toasted pecans and a white balsamic vinaigrette.

Homebaked Desserts

Crème Brûlée
$12.00

Tahitian vanilla bean, served slightly chilled with a sugared crust, caramelized to order.

Hannah's Apple Crunch
$12.00

A Tavern recipe handed down from Hannah Davis, first widow of the Revolution. Hudson Valley apples, crumb topping, whipped cream.

The American Bread Pudding
$12.00

Made with sweet muffins, finished with an American rye Chantilly Cream.

New York Cheesecake
$12.00

Individual cakes, Graham cracker crust, sweet whipped cream.

Austrian Linzer Torte
$12.00

Almond crust, raspberry filled, topped with sweet whip cream.

Chocopeanutbutta Pie
$12.00

Individual pie, chocolate crust, decadent peanut butter filling and tempered chocolate.

Salted Caramel Boudino
$12.00

Salted caramel sauce layers, Oreo crumbles, salted pretzel rod.

Lemon Shortbread Tart
$12.00

Fresh berries, chantilly cream.

Chocolate Lava Cake
$12.00

Specialty Coffees & Cordials

'76 Washington's Coffee

Laird's Applejack (Washington's favorite), dark rum, sweet cream.

The Steaming Ooh La La

Amaretto, Irish Cream and sweet whipped Chantilly Cream.

Pearl River Coffee

'Irish' coffee with Jameson and whipped cream.

Traditional Favorites

Kahlúa (Mexican), Tia Maria (Jamaican), Bailey's & Frangelico (Nutty Irishman).

Mozart Coffee- Artisan Chocolate and Bourbon

Mozart chocolate cream, American bourbon.

Espresso Martini

Van Gogh espresso vodka, kahlua, shot of espresso.

Paco's Chocolate

Chocolate liqueur, vanilla vodka, creme de cacao.

Creme Brulee Martini

Vanilla vodka, liqueur 43, Frangelico, cream, brown sugar rim.

Young Patriots

$3 for drinks and $4 for the sweet treats.

The Major Andre
$17.76

Hamburger & fries or cheeseburger & fries.

The Benedict Arnold
$17.76

Pasta with marinara sauce or pasta with or without butter.

The Martha Washington
$17.76

Chicken tenders & French fries.

The LaFayette
$17.76

Macaroni & cheese.

Thirsty Patriot

Milk

Regular milk or chocolate milk.

Soda

Cola, Diet Cola, Root Beer, Lemon up, Ginger Ale, Orange Soda.

Juices

Ice Tea, Orange Juice, Apple Juice, and Cranberry Juice.

Sweet Treat

Ice Cream

Vanilla or Chocolate Ice cream with an option for rainbow sprinkles!!

40 person minimum

$49/ person + bev, tax and gratuity

Menu

*Cheese & Fruit Platter*
SALADS:
Marinated Mushrooms
Balsamic Glazed Tomatoes & Fresh Mozzarella
Cucumber Dill Tomato Salad
Pasta Salad
Tossed Salad with Balsamic Dressing
Chinois Salad with Ginger Soy Dressing
*Grilled Vegetable Platter with Balsamic Glaze*
----------------------------------------------------------------
Gigli Pasta Pesto Primavera
Eggplant Parmesan
Baked Atlantic Salmon with Citrus vin Blanc
‘76 House Pot Roast with Red Cabbage
Sautéed Chicken Breast with Artichoke Chardonnay
Rice Pilaf
Mashed Potatoes
Steamed Seasonal Vegetable Medley
Bread Basket
CARVING STATION (Market Pricing):
Oven Roasted Boneless Turkey Breast
Country Inn Smoked Ham
Black Angus Tenderloin of Beef
Berkshire Rosemary Roasted Loin of Pork
Garlic Crusted Stuffed Loin of Pork with Spinach, Shitake Mushrooms & Manchango Cheese

30 person minimum.

Menu

The American Luncheon

Prices begin at $44.95/pp + tax & 20% gratuity
3 course lunch package includes salad, 4 lunch entree choices, dessert, coffee, tea, and soft drinks

Champagne Luncheon

Prices begin at $48.95pp + tax & gratuity
3 course lunch package with unlimited champagne & mimosas includes salad, 4 lunch entree choices, dessert, coffee, tea, and soft drinks

Bar Packages

1. Tab by consumption
2. Beer & Wine $30/pp (3 Hr party)
3. Open Bar $45/pp (3 Hr party)

Stationary Decorative Beverage Display
$150.00

You Choose Two:
1. Sangria ( Red or White)
2. Bloody Mary
3. Bellini
4. Mimosa

ADDITIONAL ITEMS:
One Hour of Passed Hors D’oeuvres
$15.00/pp

Potato Pancakes, Chicken Satay, Stuffed Mushrooms, Spanakopita, Teriyaki Beef Skewers,
Swedish & Marinara Meatballs plus more

Stationary Hors D’oeuvers
$75.00/+

International Cheese & Fruit Board
Hummus & Chips
Bruschetta with Garlic Crostini

SALADS:
Chinois Salad

Napa cabbage, romaine, carrot, bell pepper, cashews, wontons, soy ginger dressing

Garden Green Salad

Mixed greens & garden vegetables with balsamic vinaigrette

MEAT:
‘76 Famous Yankee Pot Roast

Popover, sweet yet sour red cabbage, mashed potatoes

Meatloaf

With a rich brown gravy over mashed potatoes

FISH:
Pan-Roasted Faroe Island Salmon

Citrus vin blanc, rice pilaf

Shrimp Scampi

White wine, garlic, fresh herbs and tomato brunoise, rice pilaf

CHICKEN:
Artichoke-Chardonnay Chicken

Sautéed organic chicken breast with artichoke, sundried tomato in a lemon chardonnay sauce

Classic Chicken Francese

Egg-battered breast with capers and diced tomato, lemon Chardonnay sauce, over linguine or rice pilaf

VEGETARIAN/VEGAN:
Pasta Primavera

Seasonal vegetables sauteed in a creamy garlic, white wine & extra virgin olive oil over gigli pasta

Vegan Vegetable Risotto

Fresh vegetables, vegan bouillon, coconut milk, imported Arborio rice

Vegan Moussaka

An entirely plant-based interpretation of a classic (vegan & gluten free)

DESSERT:
Hannah Davis Apple Crunch

With Chantilly cream

Chocolate Ganache Cake

With Chantilly Cream

New York Cheesecake

With fresh whipped cream

Austrian Linzer Torte

Almond pastry with raspberry

Menu

3 Course Dinner Package

$54.95/Person +tax, and 20% gratuity
This package includes a salad, 4 dinner entree choices, & dessert

4 Course Dinner Package

$58.95/Person +Tax and gratuity
This package includes Thanksgiving Spring Roll appetizer, salad, 4 dinner entree choices, & dessert

Bar Packages

1. Tab by consumption
2. Beer & Wine $30/person (3 Hr party)
3. Open Bar $45/person (3 Hr party

Champagne Toast
$1.50/person
Stationary Drink Station
$150.00

Two Drink options:
Sangria ( Red or White)
Bloody Mary
Bellini
Mimosa

SALADS:
Chinois Salad

Napa cabbage, romaine, carrot, bell pepper, cashews, wontons, soy ginger dressing

Garden Green Salad

Mixed greens & garden vegetables with balsamic vinaigrette

MEAT:
‘76 Famous Yankee Pot Roast

Popover, sweet yet sour red cabbage, mashed potato

Angus Chateaubriand

Sauce bearnaise, Yukon gold mashed potatoes

Grilled Boneless Loin of Pork

Hudson Valley apple brandy glaze, mashed sweet potato

CHICKEN:
Artichoke-Chardonnay Chicken

Sauteed organic chicken breast with artichokes, sun-dried tomatoes, lemon chardonnay sauce, with rice pilaf

Classic Chicken Francaise

Egg battered breast with capers & diced tomatoes, lemon Chardonnay sauce, rice pilaf

Classic Chicken Cordon Blue

Virginia Ham, gruyere, golden crust, cognac-creme

Chicken Marsala

Organic chicken breast sauteed with mushrooms and marsala wine

FISH:
Pan-Roasted Faroe Island Salmon

Citrus vin blanc, rice pilaf

Shrimp Scampi

Served over rice pilaf, with white wine, garlic, fresh herbs and tomato brunoise

VEGETARIAN/VEGAN:
Pasta Primavera

Seasonal vegetables sauteed in creamy garlic, white wine & extra virgin olive oil over gigli pasta

Vegan Vegetable Risotto

Fresh vegetables, vegan bouillon, coconut milk, imported Arborio rice

Vegan Moussaka

An entirely plant based interpretation of a classic (vegan & gluten free)

DESSERT:
Hannah Davis Apple Crunch with Chantilly Cream
Chocolate Ganache Cake with Chantilly Cream
New York Cheesecake with Homemade Whipped Cream
Austrian Linzer Torte Almond Pastry with Raspberry
ADD ON ITEMS:
One Hour of Passed Hors D’oeuvers

$15/person + tax & gratuity
Potato Pancakes, Chicken Satay, Stuffed Mushrooms, Spanakopita, Teriyaki Beef Skewers, Swedish Meatballs

Stationary Hors D’oeuvers
$75.00/+

International Cheese & Fruit Board
Hummus & Chips
Bruschetta with Garlic Crostini

Imported Cheese & Meat Board
$125.00